Jallianwala Bagh Massacre: History, cinema, and a legacy of loss in Rang De Basanti and Sardar Udham

While Sardar Udham immerses us in the raw emotional trauma of that horrific day, Rang De Basanti holds up a mirror, asking us how far we’ve really come.

April 13, 1919 — a date we’ve all memorised. But it’s more than just a chapter in textbooks. It’s a scar etched into our collective memory, a day when humanity vanished, and the blood-soaked soil of Jallianwala Bagh bore witness to one of the darkest moments in India’s colonial past. It was a massacre, not a misjudgment. It was the cold execution of a defenceless gathering by the white-skinned overlords of a crumbling empire, terrified of losing their grip on a rising colony.

General Dyer, whether acting alone or as a pawn of higher imperial command, gave the fatal order. And without resistance, Indian soldiers — fellow countrymen in khaki — turned their rifles on their own people. One exit. No escape. Bullets rained down on peaceful protestors trapped inside a walled garden, whose only means of survival was to feign death amid a pile of fallen bodies. Blood turned the earth red. The nearby well became a tomb for women and children who leapt in, desperate to avoid the hail of bullets. And as if that brutality wasn’t enough, a curfew ensured that the wounded received no help. Even medicine cried that night, helpless to heal.

You can read about it, recite the stats, or memorize the names, but it’s only when you stand in Amritsar — when you trace your fingers along the bullet holes or peer into that well — that the horror truly comes alive. Still, it took cinema to bring emotional reckoning into the modern consciousness. While many films have attempted to revisit the massacre, only Rang De Basanti and Sardar Udham succeeded in delivering something beyond history — they gave us truth. One through the weight of memory, the other through the lens of political rage.

Also Read: #TheAfterHour: In conversation with Ram Madhvani, Shantanu and Shatrujeet about their newest series, Waking of a Nation and more

Sardar Udham – The haunting emotional weight of the massacre

At the heart of Sardar Udham lies one unshakable truth — there are some traumas that don’t end with the last bullet fired. The massacre was not just an incident for Udham Singh; it became his life’s purpose. The man who would go on to assassinate Michael O’Dwyer wasn’t driven by revenge, but by a pain so profound it could only be silenced with action. He knew he would be hanged. He walked toward death with eyes wide open — and that’s what makes it so powerful.

The film’s most soul-stirring moment is a 12-minute, near-silent sequence where a young Udham staggers through Jallianwala Bagh in the aftermath. He’s not the revolutionary here — just a broken boy trying to carry mangled bodies to a nearby clinic. His back buckles, his knees tremble, but he keeps going. Every whisper from a dying child, every face contorted in pain, every gasp from him breaks you a little more. The silence isn’t empty — it’s deafening. And in that silence, you understand not just Udham Singh’s pain, but the inherited grief of a nation that never received an apology. The burden of the pile of bodies, of blood-soaked soil and unanswered cries, still lingers — and the film forces you to carry that weight, if only for a moment.

Rang De Basanti – The political commentary 

While Sardar Udham is a quiet storm, Rang De Basanti is a roaring fire — a political call to arms masked as a youth drama. It draws a parallel between the revolutionaries of the past and the apathetic youth of the present, challenging them to rise not just in memory, but in action. The Jallianwala Bagh scene is recreated, but this time, the one shouting “Open fire!” isn’t a British general — it’s a brown-skinned Indian defense minister. And the ones being gunned down? Innocent citizens who are patriotically doing their jobs for the country.

It flips history to show that tyranny doesn’t always wear foreign skin. Sometimes, it comes from within. The defense minister, blinded by greed, purchases faulty aircrafts that cost the life of a young pilot — the only character who believed in changing the system from the inside. His death sparks a rebellion in his friends, who once thought politics was just background noise. In recreating the past through their college play, they discover that the fight for justice never truly ends — it just changes faces. Rang De Basanti doesn’t romanticize sacrifice; it questions it. It screams that when those in power repeat the crimes of the colonizers, the youth must pick up the mantle — not just to protest, but to protect the ideals the past bled for.

Two Films. One Tragedy. Endless Echoes. Sometimes, it takes the silver screen to make sure we never forget. Moreover remind us that history is not just meant to be remembered — it’s meant to be felt, questioned, and, when necessary, relived. 

For more such stories, follow us on @socialketchupbinge.